NO. No no no no no no no no! Several points: Murdy doesn't like Scream, he was "trusted" with the character for the Scream 4 Your Life Terror Tram and it was absolutely awful, one of the main reasons it was awful is it had no identifiers to the franchise that makes it iconic such as the garage door scene, Casey Becker hanging from a tree, a gutted Steven Orth, the movie theater scene, the barn, etc..
We need a legitimate adaptation of the four movies or at least the first film. Personally, I think the entire series would be much more fun, alternating some scenes they missed for a follow up year. But I NEED to see the opening sequence, the garage door, and the finale brought to life. The movie theater and the barn/Stab-A-thon, hospital, or any sequences from Scream 3 (the prop room, the mansion) would be a bonus.