I went last night. My rankings:
9. Lunatics Playground 3D: You Won't Stand a Chance - 6/10. This wasn't the total disaster I was expecting but it was still pretty mediocre. Maybe if half the actors weren't standing in the open this would have been a better house. There are so many bland sets for a colorful house.
8. The Walking Dead - 7/10. Well, it was better than last year. I was one behind on the scares but even then I'm not sure I would have been too scared just because this series has been done to death at the event.
7. The Exorcist - 7.5/10. The recreation of the bedroom scenes were great, but I didn't really get any scares. The only things even close to scares were Father Karras and the last Reagan reaching out to me. The vomit room wasn't as bad as people made it out to be; I could barely smell it
6. Ghost Town: The Curse of Lightning Gulch - 8/10. I had a great run through this house and caught most of the actors. Notice that I didn't say scares; that's because this house isn't scary AT ALL. The sets are gorgeous and there's a fun atmosphere at least. I was surprised at how short the house was, though maybe it's because I was able to walk through it fast.
5. American Horror Story - 8/10. Good house. I caught a few scares in the Hotel stretch of the house, but I was one behind for the majority of the house. The sets were pretty faithfully, but I'm disappointed in how much of Freakshow got left out of the house. Definitely looking forward to next year's house.
4. Texas Chain Saw Massacre - 8.5/10. Oooooooooooooh boy are those Leatherfaces terrifying! Faithful recreation of the movie. The house was a bit short, but they crammed a lot of material into it.
3. Tomb of the Ancients - 8.5/10. I didn't directly catch any scares, but that didn't stop me from being scared in this house. Amazing sets and great costume design. If I caught some scares this might have been HOTY for me. Oh, and Crocolion looks great.
2. Krampus - 9.5/10. I was surprised how great this house was. I caught every scare except the attic scares in the house. People have been complaining about how the elves take up most of the scares, but that wasn't an issue for me; they made the house terrifying. Kudos to the cast. The gingerbread scene smelled delicious!
1. Halloween: Hell Comes to Haddonfield - 10/10. This is easily my HOTY and it surpasses the original house. Even with visible boo holes, the Michaels scared the hell out me! The cast brought their A-game to this house. Great job to everyone involved in this house.
The zones were meh, you could rank them any way. Overall, the event was solid. Not as good as 25 but it might be better than 24.