Said it in the other thread, but you're not getting the best Finns experience if you sit and eat during S&S. It's too packed to let the servers maneuver effectively, and the kitchen is just slammed. And then if you don't ask for your check by like 5:20, you're not going to be able to take advantage of the early opening anyway. I say this because I see bad reviews every year that I don't think are typical, and it's usually because someone sat down at 4:30.
If your night will be absolutely ruined if you don't see AHS, Kitty is your only choice.
Given the lack of weenies among the back houses this year, and the fact that soundstages work better in the daylight than tents, I don't see any strategic advantage to Simpsons. Tho it is easily the most chill of the three S&S areas (man I miss being able to enjoy a beer in Knockturn Alley while I waited).