Man...having gone for numerous years, I hate to say it but after reading a ton of hype about this year being GOATed, I left disappointed. I understand it was more crowded than usual, and feel free to hate me for it, but even for being "book report" IP houses, I felt as if FNAF and Fallout were wasted IPs with their potential. Terrifier was the saving grace this year in the IP department, also maybe WWE.
For reference, last year Ghostbusters and A Quiet Place were my least favorite, and I would still rate them higher than FNAF and Fallout.
Rankings:
10. FNAF 2/10
Aside from the opening room with the animatronics, I feel the rest of the house fell short. I understand the potential limitations with the puppets and costumes, but there was no thrill at all. Yes, the sets were spot-on but I even think they could've done better with the walk-up to the facade, more in a style of Terrifier, so you could take in the entrance to the pizzeria in all of it's grandiose, instead of a bad angled approach. Also disappointed I wasted a stay and scream here, but also realize that was the only reasonable way to see it.
9. Fallout 3/10
I had a lot of excitement for this one. I love the games, I love the show. I just felt as if the story was rushed, maybe could've been more focused and reserved for certain scenes in the show, instead of just a room by room cascade of it all. Also the makeup for the Ghoul I was disappointed it was just a rubber mask, unless they usually have used something else. Again, missing any sense of thrill to me, although I understand most IPs are approached with what I would call a "book report" style house. That being said, I have experienced some great ones, take WWE for an example or HOTC.
8. Dolls 5/10
Went in with high expectations of this one, having missed previous Doll houses like Dollhouse of the Damned. To me the sets were too "big", allowing you to see the scares coming. The use of smells was great, I think a burnt plastic then chocolate in the easy bake oven section. I appreciate the creative side of it however, and the easter eggs of BZZCON batteries and the scale of it, like with us walking through being "small".
7. Hatchet and Chains 7/10
This was a fun one. Tiny details such as one scene having smoke coming from the bullet holes after the shootout. I also liked this one from Slaughter Sinema last year. The train effect was cool, and the facade gets bonus points as well. Also "three-dimensional" in a sense of stuff above you, not just on your plane of viewing.
6. Graves of Flesh 7/10
Took a second time through this one to bring it up in my ratings. With the tall walls, it did a great job at making you feel "under the ground". Only weak spot for me was redundant characters, like the flesh eats, as well as the futuristic things and the random glowy sack in the beginning. Also an awesome facade, and looking up at your grave.
5. Galkn 8/10
Beautiful house, fun costumes, great scares, and an aggressive ending room.
4. WWE 9/10
Was not too familiar with the property, just a basic understanding of Bray. Really appreciated this one, from the facade, to intricate and creative scares and awesome costumes.
3. Jason 9/10
Wasn't too happy with the first half, that being said I still thought it was fantastic and captured the camp vibe. Most houses in this location suck to me, the last house I thought used the space well was Freaky/Black Phone. Absolutely loved the gauntlet in the second half, and appreciated the halfway point with mama Voorhees.
2. El Artista 10/10
Beautiful. Golly beautiful. The right facade, the right pacing, everything about it. Perfect scares, perfect "three-dimensional" vibe. Great use of mirrors.
1. Terrifier 10/10
As I mentioned before, the saving grace of the IPs. The perfect walk up to the facade, well in-tuned actors playing Art. Great use of smells. Great use of mirrors. Also the length of this one was awesome. Fantastic scares as well.
Another complaint, which I know could be countered with "just buy express", was insane ratios of express to standby. We never buy express as we usually just bounce around by what the waits are after stay and scream (the only year we bought express was 2010). This year it seemed on this final weekend that most express lines were getting fed to the point where they were almost empty.
Going back to hearing what a great year this was, I thought last year was a weak year and would honestly rate it higher than this year.