I'm actually fall to the floor surprised when I hear some Floridians say this. When I watched Tim Tracker's blog of when he came out to my hood to ride it, I was surprised to hear that. I've always thought the Florida version is FAR better. Better treasure scene, better opening, better coaster, fire effects; a majority of stuff there seems better, even though the set-up and story are lame. Maybe it's because I've always been on it when all of the effects are working, but I just enjoy Florida's so much more.
Maybe part of the preferences may be due to local fatigue? With the exception of the treasure room (Florida's scene is just AWESOME), I do think Hollywood's dark ride scenes are better though as well as the launch sequence. I really like Orlando's coaster portion more.