From someone who's first trip unfortunately ended up coinciding with Galaxy Edge because they moved in the dates, I have been wholly surprised.
The parks do seem very quiet both DL and CA and this ended up being the perfect time to visit. We have had no issue getting on the rides we want and have actually been doing multiple run thrus on rides I would have expected impossible from an Orlando native.
Now the Galaxy Edge stuff
GE is very impressive, I would definitely put it on a level above Pandora, but I'm not a huge Star Wars fan. The amount of nods and special little things are great. Also the way they laid out everything does a pretty good job of spreading out the crowds.
The show's are cool with nice little nods, the roaming characters are fun and not terribly in your face, and overall feels very much what I think I would want it to be like. Some of this I don't know to account to DL vs DW or the area itself.
After looking at the lightsabers I do think The price tag is justified. They are Force FX (I've heard) which market for 100-150, and these come with an pin, a story, and have a lot of customization.
The food looked decent but I wouldn't put it on pandora level but dont know didn't eat it. The blue and green milk were both pretty good and I was very happy to see them be dairy free. Was more like a frozen smoothie than anything else and all 4 of us liked them.
Didn't get into the cantinas because of technical issues and crowding (day 2 before rezzies and we peaced out an hour in because my son fell asleep) but I think it sounds like most people are giving it a bum wrap. This isn't a typical theme park bar, it's more like trader Sam's with signs, menus, and mugs to prove it. The prices are high for a lot of stuff but this is DL and Cali so I dont think its absurd. Heck the prices at Knotts seemed higher for the most part. Those of you that know me and hung out with me know how much of a cheap ass I am and this all kinda seemed par for the course.
We got to do smugglers run twice, first time I was the pilot, second was a gunner with 15 min waits. There is something insanely special about first going into the falcon and then second sitting down in the pilot seat. The ride was super fun and the people we were with were all cheering, laughing, and having fun. it was a different experience than I've ever had at a theme park than I've ever had. This coming from someone that gets motion sick and generally can't stand screen rides and isn't a crazy star wars fan. The pilot did seem more fun but I also didn't totally understand what I was doing as gunner. I think engineer sounded pretty fun.
After all those words TLDR version, amazing vacation, planned on skipping GE, decided not to and am so happy we made that decision.