Personal taste is debateable, but theme is not. The hat does not fit with the well detailed entrance to the park. Same with the wand and Leave a Legacy Tombstones at Epcot. Personal taste is fair for Under New Management and Figment, but there is simply no denying the Hat is a flaw. I like the hat, not its location.
How is an over-sized hat at the end of a 1920's boulevard any different than a medieval castle at the end of a turn-of-the-century street?