If people are whining about “not scary” this year, they’re going to be whining about it no matter what. It has very little to do with reality.
And cutting down on comedy houses, both original and IP, would be intensely foolish. First, they provide the event with much-needed variety, something sorely needed in an event with ten or more houses. An endless procession of blood and guts in traditional “scary” settings will get old fast.
What’s more, comedy houses tend to feature a greater variety of settings, costumes, and effects within the house itself. Think of GB or Slaughter Sinema (or Leave it to Cleaver or Killer Klownz) vs Blood Pit or Catacombs or (ugh) any Walking Dead House. Just like dark rides, a great house depends on a variety of interesting settings.
Finally, a lot of folks (like myself) prefer the tongue-in-cheek houses.
On that note, Bettlejuice, Gremlins, Ghostbusters 2, Army of Darkness, Return of the Living Dead - or even an older film like Theatre of Blood would be great.
I’d bet on Beetlejuice.