Love: STAR WARS, EMPIRE STRIKES BACK, THE LAST JEDI, RETURN OF THE JEDI, KOTOR I/II, JEDI FALLEN ORDER (though this one is more on gameplay than story, which was fine but nothing special)
Like: THE FORCE AWAKENS, SOLO, ROGUE ONE, MANDO S1, MANDO S2 Episodes 1, 7, and 8 (even if the bit at the end rubbed me the wrong way)
Can take it or leave it: THE PHANTOM MENACE
Mostly Bad: CLONE WARS, REBELS, REVENGE OF THE SITH, the rest of MANDO S2. I read a bunch of the EU books as a tween/teen, and none of them are good, though they can be entertaining on a lizard-brain kind of level
Just bad: RISE OF SKYWALKER, ATTACK OF THE CLONES
You also talk about "Star Wars fans" as if I am not one. Quite the contrary. I have the Falcon's dice hanging from my car mirror. I went to Savi's for my birthday this year. I got married on May the 4th. I just want Star Wars to do great things, not the boring/obvious choices it's fallen into. Mando S1 felt like what I was looking for in Star Wars moving forward. New characters and stories free from the Skywalker saga. Yes, it could wink and nod here and there to them, but that's fine. S2 just threw itself MCU style into crossovers, and I found that to be distracting and disappointing.
As for your Nintendo analogies, I actually quite enjoy POKEMON LET'S GO and NEW SUPER MARIO BROS.
I'm not "upset" about anything. I just didn't like it. That's the difference between the level of fan I am and the one's I'm talking about. I didn't love a lot of this season, or where they're clearly taking the franchise. But whatever. I'm not gonna send death threats to Dave Filoni or try and run this episode's guest star's body double off instagram. Just gonna be slightly bummed that we're going to LCD moving forward.
The Marvel comparison is bad. That's a universe defined by its crossovers and it's adaptions. SW can be anything, but they've reverted to trotting out the same tired old ponies rather than letting it grow.