I finally got a chance to check out Volcano Bay on my most recent trip and was very impressed. With the caveat that I have not been to either of the Disney water parks, this surpassed my high expectations of what a highly themed water park could be. My group planned to go on Friday and then, because we all enjoyed it so much, we decided to come back Sunday and again on Monday before heading to the airport.
There's a caveat and a couple quibbles to be had, but overall this was the surprise hit of the trip for the three of us. The first caveat is that it was
very slow. We functionally didn't need Tapu Tapu at all, save for buying drinks and snacks. On Monday morning I overheard one of the lifeguards saying there were only 700 people in the entire park at 11:30 a.m. It was Very Slow.
I essentially rode the floor-drop slides until I couldn't will myself to walk up the stairs any longer and we were able to ride the water coaster multiple times on each visit. We checked out a handful of the other raft slides, most of which were better than any slides I'd experienced before (
Wild Rivers, which re-opened last year, has a handful of very fun large raft slides).
The vegetation has now grown in to the point where I hardly recognize it from pictures I saw several years ago. This is a truly lush theme park that, with the exception of climbing atop a slide tower, does an impressive job insulating you from its environs. My major quibbles are the lack of adequate theming inside the volcano in addition to the lackluster lazy river (the fearless river on the other hand ... hell yes). Otherwise, my last complaint is one I've shared elsewhere: the operations are just not great. The bartenders were largely phenomenal, but otherwise there was little communication when things went wrong.
One example: a raft conveyer was malfunctioning, causing us to stand at the top of the tower waiting for a raft for the better part of 15 minutes. At no point did either employee tell us what was going on, apologize for the delay or do anything other than stand there and look down at the lagoon below. This was a pretty common occurrence during our trip, whether it be at Volcano Bay, Islands or Universal Studios.
But that certainly didn't put a damper on what was a great experience overall. I can't imagine going back to Universal, particularly if we stay at Cabana Bay again, and not spending a couple days lounging by the Volcano.