There is something to those Sprung Tents. I also find that I enjoy those houses quite a bit more than the Soundstages or B108 with their almost boundless space.
I will say though that given the same logic, MiB and Shrek also had constraints and limitations that I don't think always worked out in their favors. You could even argue FnF Tent has a similar intimate and small scale too. While I liked The Black Phone
a lot back in HHN31, I also think Freaky and Chucky were pretty dumpy personally.
I think it's really all in the execution. Case Files, Black Phone, and Slaughter Sinema were all wonderful S-Tier houses imo, but those same locations brought us Saw 2017, Chucky: UKC, and Depths of Fear. A good house can come from anywhere, and so can a bad one.
Counterpoint to that last counterpoint: I tried looking for a comparison example for Sprung Tent 1 and uhhhh... I couldn't find a bad one haha. I guess it's really all been bangers over there at Sprung 1 after all! Maybe just don't get rid of that one!