So, Jimmy Fallon's Tonightmares was enjoyable. The experience is a fantastic package and likely the best-quality haunted attraction in New York City this year.
The location is excellent, right at 30 Rockefeller Plaza. The haunted house's best entrance is just outside the Atlas statue and down the escalator. The haunted attraction is situated on one of the lower levels of Rockefeller Center, which adds to the experience of traveling below ground to reach the haunt.
View attachment 23696
During my most recent visit on the weekend, there was a queue even before the event opened. The wait time was generally about 20 to 30 minutes, though they did stop the line and the house for about 5 to 10 minutes for a cast change.
Once past the medical doctor, guests are placed into small groups, typically 6 to 7 people. What made this experience so memorable was the pacing and how it's generated each time guests go through the haunted house. While the shared entrance and exit likely influence the pacing and groupings, they enhance the flow and overall value of the attraction.
The haunted house is very accessible to a wide audience, as it does a great job of balancing comedy and horror, especially with its connection to Jimmy Fallon. This IP haunted house is enjoyable, even if you're unfamiliar with Fallon. While combining Jimmy Fallon with horror may seem odd, it works because it incorporates recognizable Halloween iconography, like aliens and scarecrows, to create a fun experience. The attraction even takes classic Halloween monsters and directly integrates them with Jimmy Fallon, such as in a scene with a werewolf or a serial killer...
The design is claustrophobic at points. The haunted house really does feel like maze. Some rooms are so well crafted that I had to question where the exits are. It doesn't help that each group is guided by a tour guide who has a lot of fun directing attention one way, only for an actor to jump out. Again, the pacing enhances this feeling of disorientation, allowing for a more immersive experience rather than moving through in a conga line.
Getting a Horror Nights quality experience in New York City is fantastic for the price point and what it offers. I almost forgot to mention the free photo opportunity at the end of the house, which is a nice touch since most other haunted attractions charge for photos.
View attachment 23697
I highly recommend that anyone in the NYC area check this out! I'm not kidding when I say this was one of the best Horror Nights-level haunted houses I’ve ever experienced. I would love to see more standalone attractions like this from Universal in the future!