Well, the photopass thing is already included for most of the Disney AP's, so the $10 charge for the fastpass and adding the photopass will probably not influence that group's decision all that much. Given that a good chunk of Disneyland's population is AP holders, I do not really see that as being a perk. I have seen a few AP holders even ask if their photopass capabilities are going to be taken away from their pass which would force them to buy into whatever new rate they offer this system at just so that these same people can have photopass back again.
If the idea that you cannot get fastpasses unless you are physically IN one of the parks holds up, I think this will end up being an okay system (though I dislike the upcharge aspect). Granted, the connectivity in the parks as they are right now is an issue, but that should be easy enough to fix. I hope that they realize that the reservation system as set up at WDW just will not work in a locals based park.