I mean, go through the "Most Anticipated Houses" threads each year and look at how divisive quite literally every IP ever is. HHN 28's thread is full of people disappointed in Halloween 4, Stranger Things, and Horrors of Blumhouse. HHN 29's thread was very torn on Us, House of 1000 Corpses, Killer Klowns, and Stranger Things. Hell, Texas Chainsaw Massacre was one of the most divisive houses of HHN 30.
It genuinely feels like people are forgetting how divisive almost everything is with HHN fans
. A horror comedy leaning heavily on the comedy and a sci-fi movie with next to no attachment to horror would absolutely upset people.